Insurance
How to check if your plan reimburses out-of-network teletherapy (superbills)
Facts checked November 14, 2026. Operated by Alpha Origin LLC. Not medical advice.

A receipt is not a claim
Calmerry and Online-Therapy.com both say they do not take insurance payments. Each offers a receipt you can send to your insurer instead. That is out-of-network reimbursement: you pay the full fee, file the claim yourself, and the plan pays its share of what it considers a fair price. It pays only after your out-of-network deductible is met.
Insurers pay claims, not receipts. In private practice, the document that turns a payment into a claim is called a superbill: an itemized statement that carries every field a claim form asks for. Some online platforms issue something close to that. Others issue a card receipt. Find out which you will get before you count on a check.
This page is a checklist. It does not check your benefits, and it does not promise any plan will pay.
Six questions for your insurer before the first session
Call the member number on your card, or use the plan’s chat, and ask these in order. Write down the date, the rep’s name, and the call reference number. If a claim is denied later, that note is your evidence.
- Does my plan have out-of-network benefits for outpatient mental health? HMO and EPO plans often pay nothing out of network outside emergencies. PPO and POS plans usually have an out-of-network tier. Ask about your plan, not the plan type.
- What is my out-of-network deductible, and how much of it have I met this year? Many plans track it separately from the in-network deductible, and it is often much larger.
- What coinsurance applies after the deductible, and what is the allowed amount for CPT 90834 and 90837? The allowed amount is the plan’s maximum for a service. Your reimbursement is a percentage of that number, not of what the therapist charged.
- Is telehealth psychotherapy covered out of network the same way as an office visit? Do you require place-of-service code 10 or 02, or modifier 95?
- Which license types do you reimburse, and does the clinician have to be licensed in the state where I am located during the session? Ask by credential: psychologist, LCSW, LPC or LMHC, LMFT.
- How do I submit (portal, app, or paper form), and what is the filing deadline counted from the date of service?
What has to be on the superbill
If any of these lines is missing, expect a denial or a letter asking for more information. Ask the platform or therapist for a sample before you pay for the first month.
- Your name, date of birth and address, plus the member ID from your insurance card.
- The clinician’s full name, credential, license number and licensing state. Also the individual NPI (National Provider Identifier) and a tax ID. If a practice bills, add the group NPI.
- One line per session date. A monthly total with no dates is the most common reason a subscription receipt gets rejected.
- A CPT code for each session. 90791 is the intake diagnostic evaluation. Psychotherapy is coded by minutes spent live with the patient: 90832 for 16–37 minutes, 90834 for 38–52, 90837 for 53 or more. A session under 16 minutes is not reported as psychotherapy.
- Place of service: 10 if you were at home for the video session, 02 if you were somewhere else. Both are on CMS’s place-of-service code list. Some commercial plans also want modifier 95 for live video, so ask.
- An ICD-10-CM diagnosis code. No claim goes through without one, and the diagnosis becomes part of your insurer’s records. Some people pay cash for that reason alone. It is a fair trade to think about before you file.
- The fee charged, the amount you paid, and a zero balance or payment confirmation. Add the clinician’s signature if the plan’s form asks for it.
Why a subscription receipt often gets denied
Online platforms sell a monthly plan. A receipt that says “Standard plan, 4 weeks, $360” has no session dates, no CPT codes, and no clinician NPI. The claims system has nothing to price.
Messaging is the harder part. Psychotherapy codes 90832 through 90837 count minutes in a live session with you present. A week of written messages does not fit that definition. Payers that cover therapy by message usually do so in network, under their own contracts. So for a cash subscription, the part you can usually claim is the live sessions, not the messages.
Online-Therapy.com’s FAQ says it gives itemized receipts for all payments that “detail the therapy services received.” Calmerry says you can request a receipt. Neither company promises reimbursement. Before you subscribe, ask support one question: will the receipt list each live session by date, with the clinician’s NPI, a CPT code, and a place-of-service code? A yes means you can file. A no means you are paying cash.
Run the numbers before you count on a check
Here is a worked example with made-up numbers. Use your own plan’s figures from the call. The therapist charges $150 for a 53-minute video session. Your plan’s out-of-network allowed amount for 90837 is $120. Your out-of-network deductible is $2,000 and none of it is met. Coinsurance after the deductible is 40%.
Until the deductible is met, the plan pays $0 for each session. It credits $120, not $150, toward the deductible. At one session a week, that is about 17 sessions before the plan pays anything. After that, the plan pays 60% of $120, which is $72. You pay $78: your 40% of the allowed amount, plus the $30 the therapist charges above it.
That $30 gap is balance billing, and you owe it. The No Surprises Act protections against balance billing cover emergencies and certain out-of-network clinicians at in-network facilities. They do not cover therapy you chose out of network. FAIR Health’s free consumer site estimates typical charges and out-of-network payments by ZIP code. It is a sensible check on whatever number the rep gives you.
Filing, deadlines, and denials
File each month, not in one batch in December. Keep the superbill PDF, the card statement, and the call note together. Filing deadlines vary by plan, and some are short.
When the explanation of benefits (EOB) arrives, read the denial reason code before you do anything else. The usual causes can be fixed by resubmitting: a missing NPI, the wrong place-of-service code, a license type the plan does not recognize, or a monthly line with no dates. A denial because the plan has no out-of-network mental health benefit is different. That one is a coverage question.
- Employer plans are governed by ERISA. You get at least 180 days after a denial to file an internal appeal, and the plan has to decide a post-service appeal within 60 days.
- Parity: suppose your plan covers mental health at all and pays out of network for medical office visits. Federal parity rules then generally require out-of-network outpatient mental health benefits on terms no more restrictive. If your plan’s rules look stricter for therapy than for a specialist visit, name the parity rule in your appeal.
- HSA and FSA: IRS Publication 502 lists psychologist and psychiatric care as qualifying medical expenses. You can pay the subscription with HSA or FSA dollars. You cannot be reimbursed twice for the same dollars, by the plan and the account.
- Paying cash with no claim at all? Tell the provider you are self-pay and ask for a good faith estimate. If the bill comes in at least $400 above the estimate, you can start the federal dispute process within 120 days of the bill.
Which route fits
- You need the platform to bill your insurer: start with the companies that publish in-network billing. That comparison is on the insurance guide linked below.
- Your plan has a real out-of-network benefit and the deductible is already partly met: a clinician who gives a full superbill can work. Count only the live sessions as claimable.
- The out-of-network deductible is large and unmet: price the year as cash. If reimbursement comes, treat it as a bonus, not part of the budget.
- Most of your care will be written messages: plan on cash. The trials comparing messaging with live video are covered in the research guide linked below.
Next: Which platforms bill insurance directly · Cash-pay vs in-network monthly cost · Messaging vs live video: what trials show
Related providers
Overviews stay on this site. “View provider” leaves to the company’s public site (or an affiliate path only when a tracking URL is installed).
Online-Therapy.com
CBT program with optional live sessions
Direct link
Calmerry
Messaging plans with optional live video
Direct link
Sources
- Online-Therapy.com FAQ: Does Online-Therapy.com accept insurance?
- Calmerry pricing and FAQ
- APA Services: psychotherapy coding clarifications (CPT time ranges for 90832, 90834, 90837)
- CMS Place of Service Code Set (POS 02 and POS 10)
- HealthCare.gov glossary: allowed amount
- HealthCare.gov glossary: balance billing
- FAIR Health Consumer cost lookup
- U.S. Department of Labor: Filing a claim for your health benefits
- 29 CFR 2560.503-1, ERISA claims procedure (eCFR)
- U.S. Department of Labor: Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act
- IRS Publication 502: Medical and Dental Expenses
- CMS: Know your rights when not using insurance (good faith estimates)
See also How we compare and Compensation disclosure. For crisis help in the United States, call or text 988.
